Blog
Stolen Art, Copyright, and the Power of Social Media

This story started when a friend sent me a photo of a book with my painting on the cover in an Italian Bookstore. Very surprised and taken a little aback I quickly found out the publisher was Fazi Editore a fairly large book publisher in Italy. The book was by deceased author Jacob Wassermann "The Case of Mauritius " a classic. I first went to Fazi Editore website, and sure enough there was my painting, working hard to sell the book, next I went to Fazi's Instagram where I found Fazi had posted several different images of the book, after that Facebook, even more posts and one was a give away with 480 shares, they were also advertising the book on twitter. None of these posts gave credit to me. After I searched their social media pages I found the book on Amazon in Italy and the United States. Needless to say I was very upset not only had this publisher stolen my work but they failed to give me credit in any of their social media posts or in the descriptions where they where selling the book.
Amazon had the publishing date as October and that lined up with all of Fazi's social media posts. I was notified via my friend Dec 5th. I immediately contacted The Italian publishing company, surprisingly they said oh yes we know you are the artist we even put your name inside the back cover of the book. I replied, I never granted you permission to use my painting as a cover to your book. I want you to credit me in your social media posts, online sales and compensate me. They replied " we do not credit the artists in our social posts and we can only pay you $250 that is our rate."
This went back and fourth until January 25th the whole time I was very polite, and I stressed I did not want this to go any further. Fazi Editore took no action to either credit me or make any effort to pay me. During this time I contacted two copyright attorneys to see what if anything there was I could do. Both asked if I had filed a copyright with the us copyright offices, I hadn't. What this meant was if I chose to take them to court the damages I could sue for were very limited. I could only sue for what I would get for licensing a book cover, no lawyer fees, travel expenses, lost work time, or any other compensatory costs. Suing them was out of the question.
I felt so wronged Fazi Editore's theft and lack of any kind of remorse or compensation, so I decided to take action. The first thing I did was contact Amazon and let them know of the violation, then Instagram, then Facebook, anywhere they posted the book. Instagram took down there posts within hours. Next I made a Facebook post letting everyone know what had happened. Which I posted on my page and several of Fazi Editore's pages. I really did not want to do this but I didn't want them to profit from my work, I felt I had no choice.
Italy is 9 hours ahead of us so around 2 am Los Angeles time Fazi contacted me and said we are sorry we will make everything right. All the while my Facebook posts started a fire storm. Several people shared my post and exclaimed their outrage on Fazi's Facebook page. The support was overwhelming. Two different Italian media outlets even picked up the story.
http://www.lindiependente.it/lartista-scopri-un-suo-quadro-sulla-copertina-un-libro-della-fazi/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlsgePadByg&feature=youtu.be
Shocked I wrote Fazi back, "I have been trying to reach you and work something out for almost two months..." They replied we just had a meeting and we are going to release a statement and make everything alright. I was very surprised, basically they said they were just really busy and had not gotten around to paying me but always intended to. Here is their full statement ....
"From last night, we are inundated with messages of accusations and insults, worst in the tradition of the internet, on the cover of "the case of Mauritius" Jakob Wassermann, which plays a painting of the American Artist Aaron Westerberg Fine Art. We explain our point of view, the utmost transparency to our work:
- for editorial needs we have changed the cover at the last minute and in that time, it was not possible to contact the author. We still have inserted the claims of the image on the inside of the book, like we always do, in the sight of a contact with the artist, we shamefully retarded.
- the author was faster than us and in December we wrote asking a fee for the use of his work.
- at this point, we have the negotiations with the artist for the payment of the rights. We never communicated didn't want to pay. The deal has gone on for over a month because, between Christmas and problems of internal coordination, we had no way of dealing with the issue properly. We agreed to solve the problem at the next meeting.
This morning, saw the attack on the media received, we decided in a meeting in advance to compensate the author even beyond his demands economic, to compensate for our delay.
We would like to thank the many readers have written to us asking for clarification on the issue in a calm way, disbelieving of our behaviour.
But we must also admit that the ferocity and the malice demonstrated by people who were unaware of the whole matter in respect of professionals who every day work with dedication and honesty, it scares us and terribly sad.
This morning we woke up with messages of accusations and insults regarding the cover of «Il caso Maurizius» by Jakob Wassermann, which reports a painting by the american artist Aaron Westerberg Fine Art. We explain our point of view, with the maximum transparency that has always characterized our work:
- for editorial reasons we changed the cover at the last minute and at the time we shamefully didn’t contact the author. However, we did insert the credits of the artwork inside the book, as we always do. We are guilty of not having contacted him swiftly.
- the author wrote to us in december asking a compensation for the use of his work.
- at this point, we started a negotiation with the artist for the payment. We NEVER said that we wouldn’t pay him. Due to the holidays and the absence of our publisher, who was outside of Italy and just came back, we didn’t get a chance to properly address the issue. We agreed to discuss the issue at the next meeting.
This morning, after all the attacks we received, we anticipated the meeting and decided to pay the artist more than his demands.
We want to thank the many readers who have written to us calmly asking for an explanation.
But we must admit that the ferocity and meanness demonstrated by individuals unaware of the whole matter against professionals who work every day with dedication and honesty, saddens and frightens us terribly."
The public saw through their statement, Fazi Editore never asked me to use my work and never contacted me. Within the next few days I negotiated a contract with them and they paid me for the use of my painting. My social media posts had worked, the Artists and Art supporters had flooded Fazi's Facebook page and Amazon listing with negative reviews, I was overwhelmed with support.
What did I learn? Copyright your images ! It isn't that much money, the US Copyright Office has an online registration system which starts for as little as $35.00 an image or for a registration fee of $55, you can register all of your art that was first published within a 12 month period. Talk to an attorney or do a little research to avoid common mistakes that can invalidate your registration, such as registering published and unpublished works on the same registration application. "Published" meaning made available for viewing, which can include posting on Facebook, showing at a gallery, or placed on your web site. Registration can be completed online at www.copyright.gov.
Number two, there are several Attorneys that specialize in copyright infringement such as The Law Firm of Higbee & Associates www.HigbeeAssociates.com and Stuart Carroll www.carrollaw.com both of whom graciously offered me advice on what my rights were. Higbee and Associates works with several service websites such as Image Rights, who you can pay a monthly fee to constantly search for your images online and if they find any violators they will file charges against the offenders.
It's a new age and there are tools Artist's can use to protect themselves. Also never underestimate the power of social media. Basically I had given up I though no way am I going to get them to acknowledge me much less pay me.




14 Responses to Stolen Art, Copyright, and the Power of Social Media
Leave a Comment